By AJ Jaffari

What happens when the heroes we’ve been taught to admire aren’t quite the people we thought they were?
American Conservatory Theater continues its season with John Proctor Is the Villain, Kimberly Belflower‘s Tony Award-nominated play, directed by Jess McLeod. Following its acclaimed Broadway run, this provocative and deeply affecting production arrives at San Francisco’s Toni Rembe Theater with an exceptional ensemble and a story that challenges audiences to reconsider everything they think they know about power, trust, and the people we choose to believe.
I was particularly excited to experience this production given the considerable buzz and critical acclaim surrounding its Broadway debut. While I had some familiarity with the premise, I wasn’t entirely prepared for just how emotionally demanding the material would become.
Set in a Georgia high school during the height of the #MeToo movement, the play follows a group of students studying Arthur Miller’s The Crucible. As their discussions about morality, reputation, and the characters they’ve been taught to admire begin to intersect with their own lives, the story becomes an increasingly uncomfortable examination of power, relationships, and the consequences of remaining silent.
One of the things I appreciated most about Belflower’s writing was how effectively it transported me back to that particular moment in time. The #MeToo movement sparked conversations that challenged our perceptions of people in positions of power, and the play captures that uncertainty with remarkable precision. It was fascinating to watch these characters navigate difficult revelations and confront situations in which there were rarely easy answers.
Admittedly, there are several moments throughout the production that are genuinely difficult to endure. The subject matter is uncomfortable, and the story doesn’t shy away from exploring the complicated emotions surrounding manipulation, betrayal, and the vulnerability of young people. Yet I found myself completely invested in how each character would respond as the circumstances continued to unfold.
One of the most memorable moments of the evening came toward the end of the production, when Bailey delivers a particularly poignant monologue. Without revealing too much, the scene placed me in the uncomfortable position of considering what it means to be a bystander. It challenged the assumption that we can ever truly know someone simply because of how they present themselves to the world.
That moment stayed with me long after the performance ended.

Where John Proctor Is the Villain truly excelled, however, was in its extraordinary ensemble.
I was genuinely blown away by the caliber of performances across the board. Every member of this company brought something meaningful to the production, and I particularly appreciated the emotional vulnerability required to tell a story of this nature.
Kyle Harris was a standout as Carter Smith, delivering a wonderfully nuanced performance that navigated the character’s complexities with impressive control. Harris brought a natural presence to the role, and I found his performance especially compelling as the story began to reveal its deeper layers.
Olivia Finkelstein was equally impressive as Beth Powell, bringing tremendous emotional honesty to the production. There was a remarkable authenticity to her portrayal, and I particularly appreciated the subtlety with which she navigated some of the play’s more difficult moments.
Lilla Crawford was another personal favorite as Shelby Holcomb. Crawford brought an incredible amount of energy and emotional depth to the role, creating a character who felt both deeply human and wonderfully distinct. Her ability to transition between moments of humor, frustration, and vulnerability was particularly impressive.
But what made this ensemble so special was that there truly wasn’t a weak performance among them.
Erika Vetter delivered a particularly memorable portrayal of Bailey Gallagher, handling some of the production’s most emotionally significant material with tremendous sensitivity and conviction. Her performance was instrumental in bringing the play’s central themes into focus.
Kaylee Kaneshiro, Varinique “V” Davis, and Stevie Allen each brought their own distinct personalities and emotional perspectives to the group of students, creating a believable dynamic that made their relationships and conflicts all the more affecting.
Mario Houle and Ameer Ali rounded out the company with equally committed performances, contributing to the authenticity and emotional complexity of the world Belflower has created.
Together, this cast demonstrated a remarkable level of trust and vulnerability. There were moments when the performances felt so natural that I almost forgot I was watching actors portraying fictional characters. It’s that kind of authenticity that makes theatre like this so powerful.

The production design was equally impressive.
Kate Noll‘s scenic design was spectacular in its simplicity. The classroom setting remained largely unchanged throughout the evening, yet it never felt limiting. Instead, the environment became an increasingly intimate space where the characters’ relationships, emotions, and revelations could take center stage. I appreciated how realistic and thoughtfully constructed the setting was, allowing the storytelling to unfold without unnecessary distractions.
Robert J. Aguilar‘s lighting design complemented the production beautifully, helping establish the shifting emotional atmosphere while maintaining the authenticity of the classroom environment.
However, my favorite technical element of the evening was undoubtedly Jeff Gardner‘s sound design.
The soundscape played an integral role in the storytelling, creating emotional transitions and reinforcing moments of tension in ways that felt incredibly intentional. I particularly appreciated how the sound design seemed to tell a story of its own, adding another layer of emotional depth without overwhelming the performances.
Under Jess McLeod‘s direction, the production maintains a wonderful sense of momentum while allowing its more emotionally demanding moments the space they deserve. I admired the precision with which the story unfolded, particularly as the tension escalated and the characters were forced to confront increasingly difficult truths.
There is a tremendous amount of sensitivity required to direct material like this, and McLeod approached it with remarkable care. The result is a production that feels both intimate and emotionally expansive, never losing sight of the humanity at the center of the story.
Ultimately, John Proctor Is the Villain is one of those rare theatrical experiences that continues to occupy your thoughts long after you’ve left the theatre.
It’s uncomfortable, thought-provoking, occasionally funny, and deeply moving. More importantly, it encourages audiences to question the narratives we’ve inherited and consider how easily our perceptions of others can be shaped by reputation, authority, and our own assumptions.
With a phenomenal ensemble, exceptional direction, and some truly remarkable production design, A.C.T. has delivered a powerful interpretation of Belflower’s acclaimed play.
This is a production I wholeheartedly recommend, not necessarily because it’s an easy evening at the theatre, but because it’s the kind of storytelling that reminds us just how important theatre can be.

Leave a Reply